The murder count in Trinidad and Tobago for 2026 so far is less than 300. The last time the murder toll was that low was 22 years ago, in 2004, when the murder toll was 260, rising from 93 in 1995. Lethal gun violence began to become a feature of criminal life from around 2000 and rose dramatically until it broke all records at 626 murders in 2024, more than twice the murders which occurred in 2004 and in 2026. It took 20 years for murders to double and two years to be cut by half from its high point—but only with the help of a state of emergency, tough policing, international help and regional cooperation. Still, it counts for something.
As murders went from 93 in 1995 to 626 in 2024, the detection rate completely collapsed. This created a textbook case of an inverse relationship between impunity and lethal violence. Literally, there was no cost to the murderer for killing someone.
Killings had no consequence.
Murder detection rates were reasonable in the 1980s. At that time, though, most violence was domestic or, of a personal nature. Suspects were known, and most killers were brought to justice. In the 1980s and 1990s, 64 out of every 100 murders were solved. Not a bad rate.
This dropped dramatically in 2000 and after.
In 2005, the detection rate was 24 per cent and 23 per cent in 2010. This was the period in which gang and firearm killings began to wreak havoc in the country. Between 2015 and 2024 were the worst years for detection of murders also. The average was 12 per cent. The worst year for detection was 2024, the same year of the highest murders, with a detection rate of 8 per cent.
Detection rates continue to be a problem now. Less than 15 per cent in 2025 and 2026, and researchers point out that even at these low detection rates, only 25 per cent are convicted, which means that even after you make an allowance for genuine innocence and errors of judgement, case preparation and evidence gathering are weak.
The detection rates for criminals following guns and narcotics seizures are very high, though. Once a seizure is made, people are generally charged. How they fare in court is another matter.
There was anti-gang legislation in 2011, 2018, and 2021. Research shows that legislation did not lead to convictions of either gang leaders or gang members. Even when large numbers of individuals during states of emergency are locked up, charges do not hold up in court. Evidence is weak; financial and digital information provided to the court is not acceptable, and intimidation of witnesses cripple the cases.
There are stories of growth of gangs, consolidation of gangs, streamlining of gangs, but there is no evidence of dismantling of gangs. The number of gangs now, in 2026, according to police estimates, is between 100 and 186, with a hard core membership of about 1,750. Leadership vacuums in gangs, whether from elimination or incarceration, are quickly filled.
While states of emergency, lockdowns, etc, lead to a reduction of murders through suppression, it does not cure anything. The gangs are still there. The links between the prison system and gangs have never stopped working. There is no evidence that intelligence is leading to evidence, evidence to conviction.
There is no evidence that the thread between prison and gangs is being broken. And the judicial and justice system does not seem to satisfy those before the courts: prisoners, defence lawyers, prosecutors, witnesses, nor the citizen. We have a broken system that has to be fixed if we want to dismantle gangs, turn intelligence into evidence, secure conviction, reduce recidivism, and deal with murders. Suppression alone is really not an answer.
Faith needs to be injected into the system, and fear and mistrust need to leave the mind of the citizen. The investigative capacity, evidence building, case preparation and judicial pipelines are what need to be fixed. Forensic work needs a major focus. A murderer is almost sure to get away. A gangster cannot seem to get convicted. And the gangs are not being dismantled and seem able to replenish.
The ZOSOs are necessary to meet the gangs where they are. But again, it is suppression and some detection, but not a lasting solution.
A value chain and a stakeholder chart both need to be drawn up to see where the bottlenecks are, to see where the connections are, to identify the vulnerabilities and the leverage points.
Then you need a comprehensive plan with honest actors to pursue the individual goals that lead to the more comprehensive goal. It has to be a whole-system approach with real leaders and honest actors dedicated to a whole-system solution. And a socio-economic dimension to all of this is vital- school, youth, household. As is the necessary house cleaning in the agencies of law and order of the State.
