Derek Achong
A convicted murderer has received a lifeline in his bid to challenge his 45-year sentence.
Appellate Judge Eleanor Donaldson-Honeywell partially upheld Dwayne Romany’s application to pursue a sentence appeal almost a decade after his conviction.
Romany was accused of killing a man during a botched robbery. He was convicted under the felony murder rule in April 2015 and sentenced to 45 years in prison.
Under the rule, the mandatory death penalty for murder is waived in circumstances where a death occurs during the commission of a lesser criminal offence.
Romany was credited for the time he spent on remand before his trial, leaving him with 37 years, three months and 20 days to serve.
In May 2016, Romany signed separate forms to challenge his conviction and sentence. However, prison officials submitted the notices to the Court of Appeal Registry months later, after the filing deadline had passed.
In April 2018, a notice of abandonment of the appeals was submitted on Romany’s behalf.
Romany claimed that a senior prison officer coerced him into signing the abandonment notice after he was placed in solitary confinement, deprived of welfare privileges and denied access to his relatives.
He later attempted to withdraw the notice, but his legal challenge was delayed by difficulties securing legal representation.
Romany also sought an extension of time to file his appeal. His lawyers, Joseph Sookoo and Elena Da Silva, argued that his initial notice of appeal had been filed late and no extension had been granted.
Justice Donaldson-Honeywell agreed with Romany’s lawyers that the abandonment notice did not need to be withdrawn because, due to the delay in filing, there was no valid appeal pending.
She found that it would not be in the interests of justice to extend the time for an appeal against the conviction. Her decision was based on several factors, including the strength of Romany’s grounds of appeal concerning the judge’s handling of his trial and the potential prejudice of a possible retrial.
However, she granted Romany an extension to appeal his sentence.
“Although the lengthy delay in applying for extended time and the public interest in finality weigh against the application, greater weight is given to the Appellant’s prompt signing of the notice appealing sentence, the Prison authorities’ delay in filing the notice, the Appellant’s subsequent efforts to obtain assistance, the severity of the sentence, and the merits of the proposed ground,” Justice Donaldson-Honeywell said.
The Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions was represented by Assistant Director of Public Prosecutions Anju Bhola.
