Senior Reporter
The garlic pork, pastelle pies and Creole stuffing might all have stayed off the table.
For Barry Finbar Bartholomew, the man whose pleasure in cooking has taken him through family recipes, international kitchens and experiments of his own, something had gone missing.
“I actually lost my passion for cooking, which was scary to say the least,” he said.
“It felt like something I used to do.”
He chose not to go into the reasons. But in the two weeks before our conversation, something had begun to change. The thought of preparing a Christmas menu felt inviting again.
“You feel more confident and less intimidated and less anxious to dive back in.”
Now, with garlic pork back on the agenda and a new dish waiting to make its Christmas debut, Finbar is finding his appetite for the work again.
The first decision was easy. Whatever else made the menu, the garlic pork had to be there. He has been preparing his version of the Portuguese Christmas favourite for about ten years, drawing on a tradition shared with him by the Pinheiro family.
Phyllis and Albert Pinheiro made garlic pork as part of their family’s Christmas celebrations.
Finbar would receive a portion, and the flavour stayed with him. Their daughter, Rosemary, eventually taught him how they prepared it.
“That was priceless information for me because I wanted to get as close as possible to their recipe.”
What impressed him was the balance. In some versions he had tasted, vinegar overwhelmed everything else. The Pinheiros’ preparation allowed the other ingredients to come through.
That became the standard he wanted to reach in his own kitchen.
“There’s no secrets in the ingredients, it’s the ratio,” he said.
Over the years, he said, his Christmas preparations have grown to involve as much as 500 pounds of pork belly.
While other cooks use different cuts, or portions from an entire pig, belly is his preference because of its layers of meat and fat.
It is a substantial undertaking for a dish whose appeal, in his telling, depends on getting the small details right.
That concern with flavour and balance began long before the Christmas orders.
His father loved making curry. Finbar remembers the attention he gave to spices, including cardamom and fennel, and his determination to achieve the right colour, consistency and taste.
Even a successful pot could leave his father thinking about what needed improving.
“He was never satisfied, although it came out really well. He still always had some problem with it. And I sort of got that trait from him, I guess.”
Indian food became an early passion.
So did experimenting with pelau.
He explored curry and jerk versions, using channa in one and his own homemade jerk paste in another.
He calls the curry preparation “curry lau”, explaining that he does not brown sugar for it as he would for a traditional pelau.
The familiar dish became a starting point for his curiosity.
Cooking, however, is only one part of Finbar’s creative life.
He worked in banking for 15 years and became a co-founder and musical director of Panazz, the steelpan ensemble that took its music to international audiences.
Recalling the band’s beginnings, he spoke about choosing musicians who understood music theory and could improvise. He wanted players who could respond in the moment.
The memories remain vivid, particularly an appearance at Boston Symphony Hall, opening for the Mighty Sparrow.
Finbar recalled the band receiving four standing ovations and audience members dancing in the aisles. The following year, he said, Panazz returned as the headline act.
There were performances in Japan and at jazz festivals, along with the demands of playing repeatedly for new audiences. Each audience, he said, deserved the same energy.
His account of those years carries the same attention to preparation and performance that emerges when he talks about food.
Culinary school later took him to New York. He recalled completing his externship at Tabla, working under the late chef Floyd Cardoz, whose cooking brought Indian flavours into an influential New York restaurant kitchen.
One of Finbar’s strongest memories is of spending his first day dicing onions.
A supervising chef inspected the pieces and explained how to make them uniform. Even an ingredient destined for the sauté pan demanded care.
Other kitchens exposed him to Jamaican food, American soul food, New Orleans cooking and Thai cuisine. Those experiences widened his interests and reinforced his respect for practical training.
Today, he gravitates towards street food and national dishes—the meals people know, love and return to.
“I just cook what I enjoy.”
That freedom is evident in his Christmas menu.
Last year, he introduced pastelle pies, taking a familiar seasonal flavour and presenting it in a form he enjoys preparing.
He readily acknowledges that he did not invent the dish. He simply knew it would work.
His description is straightforward: think of a shepherd’s pie, with cornmeal replacing the mashed potato topping. He adds a little cheese and bakes it.
The cornmeal’s texture matters. It must have the right moisture and consistency, and he is particularly enthusiastic about the pie eaten fresh from the oven.
“It’s divine.”
His Creole stuffing also returns. Like pastelles, he said, stuffing allows every cook to express a preference, with different ingredients and proportions producing a distinctly personal result.
Then there is the newcomer: smothered turkey wings.
Finbar has grown to love the dish and believes it will find an appreciative audience here. He describes wings cooked slowly in the oven for about three hours until tender in a rich gravy.
“It’s just full of thick, deep gravy, very umami.”
He was still deciding on portion sizes when we spoke.
One familiar Christmas undertaking is being approached more cautiously. Last year, he said, he prepared as many as 300 hams. For now, he does not intend to repeat that workload, although he admits requests from customers could test that decision.
He considers himself retired and usually cooks a meal once a week, often on a Saturday. Two friends are helping him with his Christmas preparations.
Yet easing back into cooking presents its own challenge when roughly 2,500 people are on his broadcast list.
“There’s not gradually stepping back in. It’s instant, you know?”
For all his enthusiasm, Finbar speaks plainly about the demands of professional cooking. Busy kitchens require speed, stamina and the willingness to keep going under pressure.
He values culinary school but believes the practical experience of restaurant work takes that learning much further. He also recognises that many accomplished cooks develop their abilities without formal training.
What matters, he tells young people considering the profession, is whether they enjoy making the food as much as eating it.
“Don’t act the passion. Have the passion. Be the passion.”
This Christmas, those words carry a personal meaning.
There is garlic pork to prepare, cornmeal to get just right and a new turkey dish to introduce. Finbar is looking forward to cooking them.
Before the first Christmas plate is served, he already has something to celebrate.
