“Maloney has good people. Not everyone is bad.” —Matthew Peters, Maloney Gardens Community Council President.
“Gulag” is the Russian acronym for “Chief Administration of Corrective Labour Camps”, the government agency that managed the Soviet Union’s forced labour and penal camps, began under Vladimir Lenin after the October 1917 Russian Revolution and expanded massively under Joseph Stalin in the late 1920s and 1930s. The camps imprisoned political dissidents, “enemies of the state,” religious leaders, intellectuals, and common criminals. Inmates were used as forced labour for massive industrialization and infrastructure projects.
Today, the word is used commonly to refer to any harsh prison, detention camp, or oppressive penal system. And I use it to describe what is happening today in Maloney Gardens. I claim literary licence.
Ten days ago, after a daylight gunfight there, Maloney Gardens was locked down for an indeterminate period. The move caught the community off guard. According to the last official census (2011) Maloney’s population was 10,768 residents. Recent estimates suggest the population is close to 30,000 in the broader catchment area, including the surrounding neighbourhoods. I have associated with many Maloney residents over a long period - tradesmen, factory hands, teachers, prison officers, government workers, students, football coaches and players. Decent, ordinary working people who, like the rest of us, want the best for themselves and their family. But yes, Maloney, like elsewhere in Trinidad and Tobago, also has a criminal underbelly. In public perception and in the media, this reality usually overshadows the daily grind of the honest majority who contribute to society in varied ways.
Today, Trinidad and Tobago is politically polarized. And race politics, with its own racist idiom, is pervasive. Demonizing citizens using a racist code, is now common. “One percent” means Arab. And “PNM people” is code for “black people”. In the racist political universe “PNM people” and the areas they inhabit do not matter - socially, politically or in human terms.
It is easier to justify the victimization of a group of people when they are dehumanized and depersonalized, stripped of their human qualities and moral worth, lacking individual lives, stories, struggles, dreams - an undifferentiated, faceless, worthless mass. Historically, from Soviet Siberia to the Nazi camps of Central and Eastern Europe, to Guantánamo and Gaza, this also involves isolating the target group through ghettos, camps, mass displacement, or institutional confinement to normalize its abuse. This is what is happening in Maloney.
Failed experiment
Matthew Peters, president of the Maloney Gardens Community Council, has condemned the lockdown’s 9 to 5 curfew, saying the law is being tested on their community. “It happened so fast and quick. It felt like they wanted to use a particular district as a guinea pig to lay out the ZOSO bill to see if it can work”. Police statements since 10 November provide these numbers: 600 apartments searched, resulting in 9 arrests (5 on pre-lockdown warrants and 4 in relation to the gunfight - no word of charges), and 49 rounds of ammunition, 8 marijuana trees and 6 guns seized. Notably, the COP has admitted that “the persons responsible may have slipped past the cordon”. Indeed.
Nobody wants a gunfight to break out on their doorstep or to feel threatened by criminals. The police HAD to do something. But is the full-fledged military occupation of an entire community of 30’000 people - including a curfew, mandatory “pass” to enter and exit (reminiscent of slavery and apartheid), loss of income by legitimate small businesses, reported harassment of innocent residents, and the alleged jamming of mobile communication and internet service - justified by these numbers? Is it not obvious that it is the innocent who are being controlled by the security forces? What were the Maloney police doing with “intelligence” before the lockdown? What is the exit strategy? Is not the long term solution to crime to be found in effective policing and community social programmes? To the contrary, the military occupation of Maloney is undermining sport and culture in the settlement.
Over the decades I have worked with many players and coaches from Maloney. The resident club, Maloney FC, is the reigning champion of the Eastern Football Association. Its coach, Shurland David, played for me in the national U21 team that defeated Colombia in the 5th place match of the 1993 Central American and Caribbean Games. The coach of SSFL’s Trinity College, Moka, Marlon Minguel, played for me in a U20 national team and Joe Public FC in the 1990s. He also played and coached in my own club, FC Santa Rosa, in the 2000s. I could give other examples. Maloney is a sporting community. But police occupation has forced the cancellation of EIG Elite Basketball League matches (played in the indoor regional complex). Night football is also affected. With terrible symbolism, two police mobile posts have been erected on a community basketball court. Is this ignorance, oversight or provocation? What does the Minister of Youth and Sport have to say about this?
The Gulag Archipelago
“Unlimited power in the hands of limited people always leads to cruelty.”
—Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, Russian author
“The Gulag Archipelago: An Experiment in Literary Investigation” is a three-volume work written between 1958 and 1968 by Russian dissident Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn. It explores life in the Soviet gulag system and the resultant loss of empathy, viewing that, not just as a side effect of imprisonment, but as an instrument of the Soviet state to break human solidarity. The loss of human empathy is a sure sign of social decay. There are people laughing - because of political rivalry - at the victimization of the law-abiding in Maloney, who they see as “PNM people”. Social scientists and historians widely consider the erosion of cross-group empathy (where compassion is reserved exclusively for one’s own group while political opponents or marginalized minorities are dehumanized) to be a primary precursor to political and social violence. We are treading in dangerous territory.
Always be careful what you ask for. You may get it. In this “whatabout” society we inhabit, we should be careful pointing to other areas where violent crimes occur and calling for “ZOSO” to be imposed on innocent citizens there. The Maloney occupation is bad policing, bad politics and bad public relations, and we should not make the case for it to be rolled out across the country. This only promotes further militarization of governance, and legal suppression of more sectors of the population that, in our limited, binary political landscape, are perceived by some as “anti-government”. Opposition to “ZOSO” is not “PNM” behaviour. Rather, silence is consent. So the Maloney community organization has spoken out against the use of its people as “guinea pigs”. Who feels it knows it. By all means the police must fight crime, but we should not accept a Trini gulag archipelago as the price of them doing so. “The authorities” need to focus their minds and money on effective policing and social interventions that serve all of us - irrespective of race or political affiliation - not on military occupation of so-called “hot spot” communities. Real people with real lives live there.
FREE MALONEY
Derron Sandy is a prize-winning poet from Maloney. He has written a poem every day since the Maloney occupation began. I close by letting him speak:
“Day Five. How to turn a community into a nest of crime: First, turn the place into grime; Make the building black with slime, so anyone who peep in from the outside will be like “wayyyys, like inside dey is a waste”; Make the grass grow Jumanji high and take away the garbage cage; And the naysayers will say “it would be clever, if the community could just come together and clean it; Well, for the record, been there, done that; But if HDC ain’t seeing their responsibility you can’t expect continuous responses from we; Now yuh turn the nation against we, give the media a story that we outta control and every day gangs running the city; Watch out, children and women running, Oh God, allyuh have pity; Inside dey is a zoo, so they close the Emperor Valley; Take way we best things, sport and culture, cause that’s a night time activity; Leave them inside to hide their finest hours; Publish the minority who welcome the lockdown so the ones who want freedom will silence and cower; Find eight marijuana plant in a bushy area; by the way is HDC who have bush in the area; Arrest eight people so you could say “look, the zoo so wielding power, look we doing something, the place needed a shower of authority and military”; And every minute we losing financially and sanity, and yuh waiting for we to explode so you could squeeze on we; But we ain’t taking that bait; It’s another day, and all we will say is “make we free”. Free Maloney.”
Editor’s note: The views expressed in the preceding article are solely those of the author and do not reflect the views of any organisation in which he is a stakeholder.
