Senior Reporter
derek.achong@guardian.co.tt
A businessman has been ordered to pay a couple more than $250,000 in compensation for trespassing on their land after mistakenly believing it was part of a neighbouring property he had purchased.
High Court Judge Westmin James made the order on Wednesday in a case brought by the doctor and his wife against the businessman.
The compensation was based on the businessman’s concession, made when the case came up for trial, that the couple had a better claim to the land than he did.
However, Justice James dismissed the couple’s assault claim against the businessman.
The lawsuit concerned an 8,000-square-foot parcel of land at Bel Air, La Romaine, behind the couple’s home.
The couple acknowledged that the disputed property was State land but claimed they had been in uninterrupted possession of it for almost three decades. They said they had graded and cultivated the land, fenced it and erected a small garden shed.
The businessman initially claimed the land was part of a larger parcel he had purchased in 2016. He said he believed the couple was illegally claiming possession of it.
The couple alleged that, over several days in September 2023, the businessman and his agents demolished their fence and bulldozed their shed, trees and plants.
They also claimed he told them he was a firearm user’s licence (FUL) holder with several legal firearms, threatened to “empty a clip” on their son, and threatened to demolish their wall, driveway and garage.
In support of the assault claim, the couple’s lawyer, Senior Counsel Sophia Chote, asked Justice James to consider the businessman’s statements over several days as a single course of events.
The businessman’s lawyers, Kiel Taklalsingh and Chinele Ramrattan, argued that there could be no cumulative assault. They said the couple had to have feared the imminent use of force and that the businessman had to have been able to carry it out. They also argued that his statement about being an FUL holder did not amount to a threat.
Justice James agreed that the assault claim had not been proven.
“An assault is not established by the cumulative effect of a series of encounters, none of which itself caused an apprehension of immediate unlawful force,” he said.
He noted that the FUL statement did not mean the businessman had a gun in his possession and was about to draw it. He also pointed out that the couple’s son, to whom the “empty a clip” comment was allegedly directed, was not a party to the case.
Justice James said his decision did not endorse the businessman’s conduct.
“A remark of that kind, made by a stranger in a dispute at the bottom of someone’s garden, is calculated to intimidate and it plainly did. The Claimant’s distress was genuine,” he said.
The couple sought almost $1 million in compensation for trespass. Justice James awarded $260,967.64, based on his assessment of the costs of damage to the couple’s fencing, trees and drainage.
“The sums claimed for reinstatement were, on any view, far in excess of a reasonable cost of restoring what was there,” he said.
Justice James also granted an injunction barring the businessman from trespassing on the property again or harassing or threatening the couple and their family members.
The businessman was ordered to pay $36,841.17 in legal costs.
The couple was also represented by Samantha Ramsaran.
