Checks and balances are crucial in both the public and private sectors. They help ensure that officials and others in positions of authority exercise their powers fairly, responsibly and within the law. In an ideal society, they would prevent positions from being abused for personal gain, promote accountability and curb the misuse of power.
We do not live in an ideal society. Despite the public sector’s many layers of red tape, checks and balances are sometimes ignored. Too often, red tape seems to suppress progress rather than ensure that proper safeguards are maintained.
Charitable work is a core part of the Scouting programme, and the group in which my children participate is committed to community service. Several times a year, the group conducts outreach visits to homes for the elderly and children’s homes.
Visits to children’s homes are particularly heartbreaking. To be clear, the fault does not lie with the caregivers. It lies with the Children’s Authority, the government agency responsible for the protection, care and safeguarding of children.
Some children are placed in these homes rather than being considered for foster care. Adoption can be a long and tedious process, so relief may be slow to come. Some children are unable to attend school, not because of their own unwillingness or their caregivers’ inability to help, but because of delays in processing school transfers or arranging school placements.
In Trinidad and Tobago, adoption can take several forms. I will focus on the two main types: open and closed adoption. In an open adoption, the biological and adoptive parents know one another. In some cases, people adopt children who are related to them or whose families they know. Applications for these adoptions are filed through the court and can be processed relatively quickly, provided all relevant information is submitted.
In a closed adoption, a child is adopted through the Children’s Authority, and the biological and adoptive parents do not know one another. I take issue with the length of time it takes to process closed-adoption applications. I am also concerned about the even longer wait for a child to be placed with an adoptive family. I appreciate the need to ensure that prospective adoptive parents meet all the necessary requirements, but the process could be smoother and more timely.
A child in the Authority’s care is not automatically available for adoption. The child must first be freed for adoption. This process involves placing the child in the Authority’s care, conducting a background investigation, obtaining the biological parents’ consent, assessing the child, having the board review the case and, finally, approaching the courts.
Given the red tape that characterises so many processes, this can take a long time. While the months pass, children remain in designated homes instead of entering foster care, which may provide a more nurturing environment. As families work to navigate the system, foster care could give children security, affection, a sense of belonging and stability. A child placed in a suitable foster home may also be better able to address emotional or mental effects stemming from earlier experiences.
Fostering is a less cumbersome process and can provide short-term support while children await adoption approval or a match with an adoptive family.
It is fair to ask whether the Authority has adopted a sufficiently active and sustained approach to public education and the recruitment of foster parents. Sadly, we often fail to educate the public, leaving interested people to find their own way. For several years, I have raised concerns about the lack of effective promotion of organ donation and efforts to encourage people to donate. Foster care is similar. What has the Authority done to make people aware of the benefits of fostering and the difference it can make in a child’s life?
Red tape in the closed-adoption process will not disappear simply because one or two people have raised concerns. But the Children’s Authority should regularly evaluate how well it is performing its functions and take the necessary steps to improve the system. Given its responsibility to protect vulnerable children, the Authority must not be content with the status quo.
If the number of people who have completed the adoption process and are on a waiting list exceeds the number of children freed for adoption, there may still be many people willing and able to foster children living in community homes. Those children should not be denied the chance to live with a welcoming family simply because no one has told prospective foster parents how they can help.
Pavitra Ramharack is Head of Chambers at Pavitra Ramharack Attorneys at Law and can be reached at ramharack_pavitra@outlook.com
