Spicy drinks are having a moment, and it’s no longer just standard spicy margs and bloody marys. Bartenders are getting experimental to create the perfect combination with a kick.
“The same way that you want to season a steak or a pork chop, you want to add multiple layers. And I think spice does that if you do it the right way,” says Turner Greaves, bartender at New York’s Sip and Guzzle.
He makes a tequila highball called Doctor Green which he describes as “super-herbaceous, vegetal, a little bitter. It’s got tomatillo, green apple, shiso, horseradish, and then you can make it spicier with a little serrano pepper on the side.”
Customers get to add more spice with a little spice dropper delivered with their serve.
James Stevenson, co-founder of Brutes of Mayfair cocktail bar in London, says drinks were very sweet when he started out 20 years ago, and now consumers’ tastes have shifted.
“I think there’s a real movement toward savoury cocktails,” he says. “Every drink we put on the menu that is more savoury or has a pickled element or spice element tends to be our bestseller.”
Stevenson makes a mezcal-based Bagheera which he describes as a turbo-spiced margarita.
“We juice (blend) rather than shaking the drink, with fresh chile and coriander,” he says. They make a fresh syrup, adding tequila and freshly squeezed lime, and finish off the drink with a house-made tajin salt rim.
It’s no coincidence both bartenders picked agave-based spirits—tequila and mezcal—for their spicy offerings.
Stevenson explains that a lot of the flavour profiles you get from agaves are fresher, more vegetal than other spirits. “They’re just very akin to chiles” he says. Noting that tequila pairs well with salt, he adds, “Spice and savoury flavours are just a natural kinship.”
Alex Lyoness, bar manager at London’s FlipDog, makes his Late Night cocktail with a hint of an after-hours kebab and pickles. He uses a white tequila and a Raicilla (an agave similar to mezcal). Soy sauce brings a deep flavour, he says, and a homemade chile tincture spices things up.
He then adds an onion and olive brine “like the ultimate dirty martini,” and garnishes with a bright pink pickled turnip.
But chiles aren’t the only way to add spice. Lyoness says you’re looking to create a “mouthfeel.” He uses Sichuan peppercorns and the Timur berry, which he says has a cool, numbing quality. “What you’re looking for is that tingling across the palate,” he says.
Greaves recommends bringing a little classic cooking into your drinks.
“You can add ginger, you can add garlic cloves, and star anise and fennel into these drinks, and it adds so many different elements of pepper, of spice. Go home and then throw cayenne into a margarita,” he says.
To judge the heat, try to read it on your palate, says Greaves: “If it starts creeping all the way down to your esophagus, I think that’s definitely a spice level that you can loosen up a bit.”
A good spicy drink should “give you the itches on the sides of your mouth” but not overwhelm, he says.
And don’t forget that no two chiles are the same.
“It’s all about tasting, trying and tweaking,” Anderson says.
For a spicy rim, mix any spices from your cupboard with a good rock salt, says Anderson. (You can freshly grind the spices for a more aromatic and vibrant mix.)
He recommends coriander seed for a more citrusy mix, and black pepper or cardamom powder for a savoury feel. You can even try adding fruit powders.
“Something like a freeze-dried strawberry, freeze-dried raspberry, with a little bit of spice. It’s great,” Anderson says.
Then, simply run a lemon or lime wedge along the rim of your glass and gently roll it in a shallow plate of the salt mix.
