Last Saturday, US President Donald Trump convened a meeting of heads of 13 countries of the hemisphere to formally establish an alliance that he conceived, under terms that his team devised, underwritten by a proclamation that he crafted, in a ceremony he alone spoke at, at a time that he determined, at a resort that he owns.
The Americas Counter Cartel Coalition (ACCC) was established by presidential proclamation. Trump’s. Not a joint communique. The first line references his leadership.
When briefed on plans for the summit at the Trump National Doral Golf Club in Florida, State Department conference staffers may have initially envisaged a setting of all of the heads at a conference table – name tags and all – with the US president.
However, the signing ceremony was the same as when the US president signs domestic legislation and executive orders – in which he sits at a small desk bearing the seal of the President of the United States, surrounded by standing staffers, friendly legislators, or beneficiaries of the bill. He was the focus.
For a smart and TV-savvy president, staging is everything. He is the boss. The clear message conveyed by the visuals was that the leaders summoned to Doral are working for him, not with him. His Secretaries of State and Defense (renamed War) delivered brief remarks of flattery to their great leader. No other leader spoke.
When he moved to the small desk and invited the other leaders to surround him, the Prime Minister of Trinidad and Tobago, Kamla Persad-Bissessar, was notable for the rapid locomotion that she summoned in getting close to the seated president. Job done, Trump got on Air Force One not long after and flew about two hours north to Dover Air Force Base to attend a ceremony, in which the remains of the first US soldiers killed in the war with Iran were brought back to the US.
The common denominator in the Iran war and the ACCC is the self-styled Secretary of War Pete Hegseth. This passage from Trump’s proclamation is worth noting.
“In furtherance of our efforts, the Secretary of War established the Americas Counter Cartel Coalition, a pledge from military leaders and representatives from 17 countries demonstrating that the region is ready to operationalise hard power to defeat these threats to our security and civilisation. We will address these grave dangers by use of any necessary resources and legally available authorities, together with our partner nations.”
Two terms stand out… “hard power” and “legally.” Hegseth has demonstrated that he is prepared to deploy the first. On the second, he has a poor record of compliance with international law. He has slashed numbers at the Judge Advocate General’s Corps (JAGS), arguing that lawyers tie the hands of warriors on the battlefield.
He is the architect of the US military’s legally unsound policy of blowing up boats they claim are ferrying drugs, and killing their occupants. To date, they’ve killed 157 people. Hegseth’s commanders killed two shipwrecked survivors in the Caribbean Sea last September, and more recently, left Iranian sailors to drown in the Indian Ocean after sinking their ship near Sri Lanka. Both actions violated Article 98 of the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea.
In Pentagon press briefings on the Iran war, Joint Chiefs Chairman Dan Caine strikes a sobering, grown-up contrast with Hegseth’s teenage-style braggadocio. His most uttered word is “lethality.” He doesn’t seem that concerned with legality.
The ACCC substitutes military force for law enforcement. The proclamation also mentions choking off financing for cartels and takes a veiled swipe at China, but there’s not a word about intelligence gathering.
The law enforcement officials in the partner nations should advise Hegseth that blowing up the boats of suspected smugglers runs counter to gathering intel on the people who give them their orders.
This column was the first to note that Doral was a gathering of the like-minded. Leaders with frosty relations with Trump – from Brazil, Colombia, Mexico and Canada – were not in attendance. But despite the presence of pro-Pinochet far-right Jose Antonio Kast of Chile and right-wing authoritarian Nayib Bukele of El Salvador, it’d only be a partial read to put proceedings in a right-wing box. Interests were varied. More on that next time.
